Air Fryer Grilled Cheese Recipe

This air fryer grilled cheese is crisp and golden on the skin and melty within the center. It is the simplest strategy to make an ideal grilled cheese sandwich!

Air fryer grilled cheese

Do you know you can make an ideal grilled cheese within the air fryer? This air fryer grilled cheese sandwich is crisp and golden on the skin and gooey within the center (I imply, take a look at that cheese pull!).

I began making this air fryer grilled cheese recipe final spring for my son Ollie, and it’s since change into my favourite strategy to make a grilled cheese. Certain, it’s fairly easy to prepare dinner one on the stovetop, however utilizing the air fryer is even simpler. Right here’s why:

I take advantage of sliced, not grated, cheese. Sandwich meeting is fast and straightforward!
Cleanup is a breeze. There’s no skillet to scrub after cooking.
You may set it and overlook it. After I make a grilled cheese on the range, I’m all the time adjusting the warmth to search out the proper steadiness of browning the bread and melting the cheese. Within the air fryer, you may go away the temperature the identical for your complete prepare dinner time. Simply bear in mind to flip midway by way of.

In case you have an air fryer, you must completely do this recipe. It’s possible you’ll by no means make a grilled cheese in a skillet once more!

Recipe ingredients - sliced bread, sliced cheese, and mayo on cutting board

Find out how to Make Grilled Cheese in an Air Fryer

This air fryer grilled cheese recipe is tremendous easy to make:

Begin by assembling the sandwich. Unfold two slices of bread with a skinny layer of butter or mayo (I feel mayo browns higher, so I like to recommend utilizing it!). Flip one slice over and prime with 2 to three slices of sharp cheddar cheese. Prime with the second slice of bread, inserting it mayo facet out.

Then, air fry it. In case your air fryer requires preheating, preheat it to 375°F. Place the sandwich within the air fryer basket and air fry till the cheese is beginning to soften and the bread is beginning to brown, 3 to five minutes. Fastidiously flip and prepare dinner for one more 2 to five minutes, or till the bread is golden brown and the cheese is totally melted.

Slice and serve!

Discover the whole recipe with measurements under.

FAQ: What air fryer do you employ?

I’ve tried many various air fryers through the years, and the Our Place Marvel Oven is my favourite. I like the flexibility of the toaster oven fashion, and it requires zero preheating. It’s additionally an amazing measurement—sufficiently small to suit on my countertop, however massive sufficient to be usable. It’s tremendous cute too!

Grilled cheese in air fryer basket

Air Fryer Grilled Cheese Suggestions

Use sliced cheese. After I make a grilled cheese on the range, I grate the cheese to assist it soften evenly. However within the air fryer, grated cheese could make a little bit of a multitude, and I discover that sliced cheese melts simply fantastic. Be happy to purchase pre-sliced cheese or slice it your self. I name for sharp cheddar on this recipe, however any good melting cheese will work. Monterey Jack, Swiss, provolone, and American are all honest recreation!
Don’t skip the mayo or butter. It’s important for serving to the bread get brown and crisp because it cooks.
You may must work in batches in case you scale up the recipe. As written, this recipe makes one air fryer grilled cheese. After all, you may scale it up, however solely prepare dinner as many sandwiches as will slot in a single layer at one time. If the air fryer basket is simply too crowded, they gained’t prepare dinner evenly.

Air fryer grilled cheese recipe

Extra Air Fryer Recipes to Strive

If you happen to love this air fryer grilled cheese, attempt considered one of these simple air fryer recipes subsequent: